Skills demonstrations

What are skills demonstrations?

Skills demonstrations are a practical way to assess a candidate’s abilities during the recruitment process. This method involves giving candidates tasks that are like the actual work they would be doing in the role. By watching how candidates handle these tasks, employers can see how well they can apply their skills in real-life situations. Skills demonstrations can help show how a candidate’s knowledge works in practice, giving a clearer picture of whether they’re ready and suitable for the job.

---

What are skills demonstrations used to evaluate?

Skills demonstrations can provide a practical and structured approach to assess candidates’ abilities, helping employers identify the best candidate for a role. Key areas typically evaluated include:

Technical skills and knowledge

• A candidate’s ability to demonstrate job-specific tasks requiring technical skills.
• Example: A software developer may be asked to debug a piece of code, or a designer might create a sample logo using design software.

Problem-solving

• How effectively candidates approach and resolve challenges, often in a realistic context.
• Example: An IT specialist might troubleshoot a simulated network issue.

Creativity and innovation

• A candidate’s ability to think innovatively and generate unique ideas to the role.
• Example: A marketing applicant could be tasked with developing a creative promotional strategy for a product launch.

Attention to detail

• Accuracy and precision in identifying errors and inconsistencies
• Example: A proofreader might review a document to identify typos and grammatical mistakes.

Communication skills

• A candidate’s effectiveness in conveying ideas clearly, both verbally and in writing.
• Example: A customer service applicant may role-play handling a difficult customer inquiry.

Time management

• The ability to complete tasks within deadlines while managing priorities.
• Example: A project manager might create a project timeline for a simulated initiative.

Adaptability and resilience

• How well a candidate adapts to new challenges or changes in work scenarios.
• Example: A consultant might respond to an unexpected client request during a role-play exercise.

Teamwork

• How effectively candidates collaborate with others.
• Example: Candidates could participate in a group activity to solve a problem together, observing their teamwork skills.

Skills demonstrations can offer a holistic way to evaluate candidates, moving beyond resumes to see how they perform in realistic scenarios aligned with the role.

---

Considerations when planning skills demonstrations

Skill demonstrations, such as work trials, take-home assignments, or on-the-job interviews, are increasingly popular in recruitment for their ability to assess candidates’ practical abilities. However, their design and implementation can impact neurodivergent candidates if not designed to be neuro-inclusive.

How do skill demonstrations help identify skills?

Skill demonstrations aim to assess abilities in real-world contexts, often bypassing biases associated with traditional interviews. For neurodivergent candidates, this approach can highlight strengths in areas such as creativity, problem-solving, or focus. A situation where a candidate excels in technical problem-solving but struggles with social interaction in verbal interviews, a well-designed task could allow all candidates to thrive.

However, the format matters. A task requiring decision-making under time constraints might unintentionally disadvantage candidates who process information more thoroughly or experience heightened anxiety under pressure. While such conditions mimic high-stakes environments, they may not reflect the everyday demands of the role, raising questions about fairness.

How does task design shape outcomes?

The design of skill demonstrations can either create opportunities or barriers. For example, a task with ambiguous instructions might appeal to candidates who thrive on open-ended challenges but could disadvantage others. Consider a situation where a candidate is asked to develop a creative solution without a clear problem definition. While this approach may suit some, others may struggle to display their strengths due to the lack of structure.

Flexibility is an essential element of the design. Design a process where candidates are given the choice to present their solution verbally, visually, or in written form. This inclusive approach can support candidates to show their strengths while reducing barriers for those who have other communication preferences.

Are take-home assignments inclusive?

Take-home assignments offer the advantage of letting candidates work at their own pace, potentially reducing pressure. However, imagine a scenario where the assignment lack’s structure or spans several hours without guidance. A candidate who thrives in structured environments may feel overwhelmed or struggle to complete the task effectively, even if they have the skills for the job. Breaking down the assignment into smaller tasks with clear expectations could provide a fairer assessment.

Can biases impact skills demonstrations?

Even with skill demonstrations, biases can impact. Consider a situation where a candidate approaches a task in an unconventional way, delivering a solution that is different to the expected method but achieves the desired outcome. If the evaluator focuses too heavily on the process rather than the results, they might undervalue the candidate’s innovative approach.

To counteract this, clear evaluation criteria focused on outcomes rather than methods could reduce subjective judgments. For instance, instead of critiquing how a problem was solved, evaluators could assess the overall solution with the task’s objectives.

Skill demonstrations can offer a neuro-inclusive way to assess a candidate’s abilities however to be a successful form of skills demonstration, the assessments must be thoughtfully designed, flexible, and use bias-aware evaluation practices.

Refer to Fair Work Australia to know when you are expected to pay someone for a skills demonstration.

---

Skills demonstration types

Follow the links below for a guide on each demonstration type.